Showing posts with label grief. Show all posts
Showing posts with label grief. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 25, 2012

web memorials


As so many others I have known, I fought it for a while, but many of us—across generations, genders, socioeconomic groups, races, cultures, and subcultures—eventually wind up joining some sort of online social network and/or creating a personal or family web page. For some, it is an additional way to communicate with loved ones, distant and near; for others, it is a way to meet new people and/or network for employment and business; and for many, it is a way to feel a sense of community and to have an opportunity to express themselves and connect with others without the limitations and social constructs and, perhaps, discomfort and awkwardness that in-person communication may indicate. Given the explosion of popularity of online communities, the growing creation of and participation in web memorials and virtual cemeteries as a bereavement ritual comes as no surprise. This relatively new phenomenon not only indicates a circular pattern of grief and its need for a voice in today’s linear and cacophonous society, but it also begets questions regarding social isolationism versus healthy interpersonal relationships in the midst of grief. These are the concepts addressed by Brian de Vries and Judy Rutherford in “Memorializing Loved Ones on the World Wide Web” (2004) and by Pamela Roberts in “The Living and the Dead: Community in the Virtual Cemetery” (2004).
Grief needs a voice. It needs a safe place to be heard—an accepting place and a patient place. Additionally, given the highly mobile culture in which we live, it needs someplace widely accessible. The creation of web memorials and virtual cemeteries as a grieving ritual fits postmodern society like a glove. As discussed by de Vries and Rutherford, unlike the highly communal sense of loss and grief reminiscent of colonial America, grief is now more commonly seen as an individual, personal affliction with a limited window for open expression. The Internet provides a valuable opportunity to grieve within a supportive, highly accessible (albeit virtual) community and process the loss without concern for whether or not the grief fits current social expectations of emotional display, length of grief, who ‘should’ grieve, and who ‘should’ be grieved. Web memorials provide a ritual to address the circular grief that society at large no longer seems necessarily capable of supporting.
The virtual community feeds the need to talk about the loss—even to talk to the lost—and allows the bereaved to process their feelings and participate in catharsis without the sense that they could be burdening others with their grief. Cyberspace is a perfect postmodern venue for maintaining relationships with our deceased loved ones without judgment. It is a “way to stay connected, no matter the distance or time” (p. 65). Evidence also indicates that this new ritual does not generally foster isolationism and is not a manifestation of clinical maladies, but is, instead, another way to remember and honor lost loved ones with the support of other families and individuals. Web memorials are interactive communities where people are able to share stories, ideas, comfort and support in the midst of difficult times.
Cyberspace offers a much-needed community, including the four elements described by McMillan and Chavis that are key to creating a psychological community: membership, influence, integration and fulfillment of needs, and shared emotional connection (1986, as cited by Roberts). Provided online is a place for the disenfranchised mourner, a virtual ear for the stories of the bereaved, and an accessible quiet venue for remembrance. While these communities may not be physical, the psychological and emotional connections that are made are no less real for those who visit them.
Considering disenfranchised mourners, I cannot help but think of my dad as an example. When my former stepmother (they had divorced) passed away in 2003, her body was cremated, the ashes were scattered at Lady Bird Lake (amid a host of poison ivy); and she specifically required that my dad be barred from any of her funeral proceedings. I suppose she was so finished with the idea of my dad that she wanted distance in life and in death. I can only speculate on her reasons, but the end result is the same: my dad’s grief, to this day, has been left stunted. My dad even jokes at the idea that the ashes were intentionally spread in poison ivy as an additional safeguard against visiting the memory of my stepmom! Perhaps, given my dad's pariah status in the community of her ex-wife, grief could be unravelled and processed and supported via website. Maybe Dad could find that there is more support and connection than previously assumed. Maybe the lines of communication stemming from that marital history could be reconnected and healed. “Online communication becomes not a substitute for direct communication, but rather an aid in communicating both on and off line” (p. 72).




References
De Vries, B., Rutherford, J. (2004). Memorializing loved ones on the world wide web. Omega—The Journal of Death and Dying, 49(1), 5-26.
Roberts, P. (2004). The living and the dead: Community in the virtual cemetery. Omega—The Journal of Death and Dying, 49(1), 57-76.

thoughts on Frankl


Reading Viktor Frankl’s Man’s Search for Meaning, I feel like my breath has been swept from my lungs.  My heart swells for the unimaginable physical and psychological suffering he witnessed and experienced; and my mind feels like a contortionist, trying to twist and stretch to wrap itself around the whys and the hows of not only those who did or did not survive, but also the whys and the hows of those who were capable of inflicting and maintaining such horrors, and everything and everyone in between. While this may seem a melodramatic introduction to a simple book analysis, it is an honest reflection of the effect Frankl's book had on me. It is a story of external torment and internal escapism; of humanism and dehumanization; of finding hope, power, truth and meaning; and of the will to survive through the most unlikely and seemingly impossible circumstances. 
       The phases of which he speaks, while generally comparable to Kubler-Ross’s widely known five stages of grief, are unique to the prison camp experience—a torturous purgatorial period of neither life nor death.  Initial admittance into this purgatory resulted in, first, shock and an unbearable flood of emotion.  Such was the intensity of these feelings that death could seem a welcome reprieve from the agony of longing, disgust, humiliation, dehumanization and physical anguish.  Secondly, however, and too late for the many who did not survive the first stage of psychological reactions, was the experience of detachment.  Apathy became a very “necessary protective shell” (p. 23) for self-preservation, and inmates regressed to “a more primitive form of mental life” (p. 28) where wants and needs were manifest in dreams and rooted in survival and normalcy rather than luxury or excess.  This is the stage in which Frankl spends the most time relaying his experience. 
I am especially inspired by and taken with the notion of inner escapism during this stage—the notion that truth and meaning for a person is all that is left when everything else has been brutally stripped away.  Some found meaning in life and the will to survive through love.  Some found it in thoughts of family, some in helping ease the suffering of others and responsibility to community, and some in the suffering itself, wearing it as a badge of courage. It was a “spiritual freedom… [an] independence of mind” that kept a small flame of hope burning despite the lack of air.  Meaning in life indicated a reason to live—goals on which to make good.  They indicated a hope for a rebirth out of purgatory and life after their own figurative death.  There is no life without death, no light without dark, no joy without sorrow, and no ease without suffering.  Those who lost sight of the potential other side of their suffering also lost the will to live.  They no longer saw the deeply buried meaning in their life.  Illness was often the clinical cause of death, but it was absolute despondency that frequently allowed the illness to take hold.  With this thought, I am reminded of my grandfather who willed himself to die within weeks of my grandmother’s passing.  Had he the motivation, he could have lived much longer, but he chose to be taken by his illness. Life was not the same without her and he no longer felt the world needed him or him, it.
       Finally, Frankl speaks of liberation: the third stage in the mental process experienced by the prisoners.  I was intrigued to find that my preconceived notions of good and evil (as had also been demonstrated in the actions of some of his inmate counterparts during their incarceration) were wrong.  It serves as a good reminder that there is no simple formula for what makes one person good and one person bad.  Other prisoners could be the most malicious characters in the camp, while Frankl speaks of a Nazi foreman who moved him to tears in offering a small piece of extra bread.  In a place where prisoners are treated as nonentities, to be acknowledged and validated through even the smallest kindness meant the world and fed his soul while his stomach still grumbled.  It is impressive that absolute power and absolute suffering—both sides—can expose both the most brutal nature of an individual as well as his humanity.  “Life in a concentration camp tore open the human soul and exposed its depths” (p. 87), and these depths were left exposed and raw upon being thrust into liberation and freedom. 
Understanding the lingering psychological and social effects of this atrocity on one generation (that experienced it directly), I find myself curious about the likely parallels between this event and the generations of slavery and oppression that are such a relatively recent part of our history.   In both contexts, individuals, groups, families, and communities have been torn apart, brutalized, and dehumanized.  In both contexts, instances of humanity and relative decency can be found even within the offending ranks. In both contexts, there have been lingering misunderstandings, anger, sadness and despondency along with powerful and inspiring acts of heroism and courage.  What can our society, our world, take from these historical lessons?  How can we use these experiences to make a change in the world today?  How can we respond to each other respectfully and with understanding, rather than reacting without considering the teachings of our past? “No group consists entirely of decent or indecent people” (p 86).  We all have the potential for good and evil.  We simply must make a choice between the two, understanding that “True saints are the ones who can absorb the evil done to them, and not pass it on to others” (anonymous).

Tuesday, July 24, 2012

dying well, living well


Throughout my start in this field--especially while in grad school--friends and family have seen the books that I read, the journals I research, and the projects for which I volunteer. Invariably, they have responded with the notion that this must be the most depressing, difficult career ever; and they would be hard pressed to want to read the things I read or do the activities I do. Actually, I tell them, it’s emotional, it’s profound, and it’s great. While the concepts of loss and death certainly evoke intense grief and various other emotions (which we, as a culture, typically avoid), it is possible to reframe the experience to find meaning. Death does not have to be viewed as a problem, but rather as an integral, natural part of life. Death is not inherently undignified. Additionally, while the experience of loss and grief is unique to each individual, they are normal aspects of life and emotional wellbeing. The most recent book with which my friends have been uncomfortable is Dying Well: Peace and Possibilities at the End of Life by Ira Byock, M.D., and these are some of the issues he addresses via stories of individual experiences with death.


Regarding his own experience, Dr. Byock discusses death being treated in the medical field, unconditionally, as a problem. Efforts are made in almost every situation to prolong the life of the individual admitted to the hospital, and the stories he cites suggest that it is treated this way out of fear of liability. Even at a sickly ninety-two years old, one woman's distant family did not want to withhold intensive treatments to prolong her life because they would then feel responsible for her death. Our society seems to base its treatment of the terminally ill on the misconception that if we do not prolong life (even in atrocious, painful, or near-death contexts), then we are the ones ending it-—we become murderers. Thus, hospitals and nursing homes, as Byock suggests, are stuck in a precarious situation. Even professionally knowing that someone is about to die, due to any cause, these institutions must be able to prove that they did “everything possible” to keep that person alive, lest the family/friends hold them liable for the death. It is not, therefore, death that is the problem, but perhaps our misguided fear of it.

“I wondered what it was permissible to die from…. even passings that should have been peaceful turned gruesome” (p. 27). As it is fear that is the problem, not death, death does not have to be undignified. It seems that our fear of it and our subsequent reaction to its inevitability are what create any perceived indignity. Byock suggests that by allowing people to reflect on their imminent death, and by opening a safe space for them to experience the emotions that accompany it, people may have a dignified, meaningful, and fulfilling end of life experience. They can confront their fears of being burdensome or of suffering—-he stresses that pain can, in fact, be managed—-as well as fears of solitude and family debt. They can take the opportunity to tie up emotional loose ends and find closure on unfinished business. Some examples: Ira was able to care for his father. Anne Marie reconnected with her sister and daughter. Some of Ira’s patients were able to let go of anger and forgive. Others held on to life long enough to achieve meaningful goals, and all that were mentioned were able to transition out of life peacefully and with dignity.

“‘What would be left undone if I died today?’ and ‘How can I live most fully in whatever time is left?’” (p. 34). These are two very simple, important questions. We take so many things for granted in our daily lives-—especially time. There will always be time to mend that relationship, to apologize, to pay off debt, to quit smoking, to climb that mountain, to learn a skill, to laugh, to cry, to express love. Then, at some point, daily life becomes daily death. It is only when the end and the loss of time becomes almost tangible that so many of us realize that we have a lot of frayed, loose ends to tie.


And with that in mind, I continue to enjoy the spectrum of experience and interactions that constitute life. I will continue to pass go.